Sunday, March 04, 2007

I Am a Terrible Person

Went to the uncle's house for dinner this evening, like we always do. I wondered if it was going to be awkward. See, I called him a hypocrite last night. I should probably feel a bit bad about that. And I do, a little. He's been going on and on about "An Inconvenient Truth". He's almost religious with it. I am surprised at how fervent he is about the whole thing. I'm not quite as convinced as he is about it all, and I brought up a dissenting opinion. Things got a little heated. I told him that, while I might not believe that the whole thing is truth, or due to man, that doesn't stop me from decreasing my energy usage a bit. I asked him what he was doing. His response was "spreading the word." I asked if he was doing anything else to decrease his personal consumption, and he is not. I told him that he was a hypocrite. He said that his doing anything about it was a drop in the bucket and it wouldn't mean anything unless government does something first. I told him that enough people put drops in the bucket, it gets full. I don't know. The whole thing kinda makes me angry. If you think people should live their lives in a specific way, doesn't it make sense to seet an example instead of waiting for someone else to do it for you? For goodness sake, the man has 5 DVD burners (was 5 VHS recorders) running at all times. He's recording all sorts of stuff off of his DVR and satellite. There's no way he can watch it all. He's got 4 computers, and it is just him. He used to have just one, then it became 4 within a couple of months. The man is almost OCD.

Still, I feel guilty that I unloaded on him. He is an incredibly sweet man, and lonely. I think old age is creeping up on him in the way it did to my grandmother. You isolate yourself and you start getting more and more extreme in your beliefs, no matter what those beliefs are. This man was very good to us through college. He gave us money every month that allowed us to see the occasional movie and keep our heads above water. We tried to pay him back, but he won't hear of it. We got a bit extravagant for his birthday this year and bought him an expensive BBQ grill. It's aobut the only way we can pay him back for his generosity.

I guess that's what makes me a heel. I should have just kept my mouth shut. I don't know why I didn't just back out of that fight. If it were my grandmother, I would have. This man isn't even remotely close to that old, so I don't think of him that way. I do now, though. It explains a lot.

I guess I owe him an apology. He hugged me last night as he left, even after we argued, so I don't think he holds it against me all that much.


Shit.

4 comments:

The Go To Guy said...

This doesn't make you a terrible person. I feel like you do and might have responded the same way. Still, I can see why you would feel bad. It's good that you got that indication though that he wasn't holding a grudge. :)

Anonymous said...

At least you didn't call him a hypocrite for using his new grill, causing irreparable harm to the atmosphere. Hopefully it was a gas grill. ;-)

Greg said...

conservation is NEVER a bad idea, so i am with you there, but what Al Gore is selling is a FAITH, not science. everything he says in AIT is either distortion, misconstrued or blatant falsehood. if you question him or his ilk, you are a heretic. i am an atompseric scientist in academia. people NEED to be skeptical.

Anonymous said...

I'm with greg on this one. Except I'll go further in saying AlGore is an enviro huckster.

I say this as an environmental scientist in Boulder, CO, where several federal scientific labs depend on the alarmism for the mega-billions that support the lifestyle they've become accustomed to unlike the simple underfunded one climatologist William Gray, the now retired hurricane predictor up the road at Colorado State University, enjoyed all his career.

Have your uncle view February's UK channel 4 documentary, “The Great Global Warming Swindle,” free online.
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=4499562022478442170
It's mostly accurate.

Next, listen to the “Climate Warming is not a Crisis?” debate from NYC, broadcast by NPR. Less than an hour, but also better when heard completely at less than 90 minutes. Here the skeptics, led by Michael Crichton, win!
Complete links here
http://motls.blogspot.com/2007/03/intelligence-squared-climate-debate.html

Also interesting are the roughly 30 minutes devoted to global warming by Michael Crichton - whose book "State of Fear" presents his skeptical views - on Charlie Rose interview show (starting at 22 minutes)
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2663847011110488414&q=charlie+rose+michael+crichton&hl=en

Finally, let me say that Christopher Horner's The Politically Incorrect Guide to Global Warming and Environmentalism" can't be beat if you really want to open minds. I'm familiar with nearly all of his citations and can therefore vouch for the accuracy of his quite jaundiced story telling.

The bottom line is this: if the debate is over, then why have all climate alarmists LOST every head-to-head debate in the past five months?

There's the one above, the one AlGore ducked with Bjorn Lomborg in February, and the brief one on "Larry King Live" last January 31 with the Weather Channel's Heidi Cullen and MIT's Richard Lindzen - just google it for a transcript and news stories.

Climate alarmism is more about politics and Gaia worship than the relevant facts and science and truth.